Journal of Experimental Botany, Vol. 51, No. 351, pp. 1705-1712,
October 2000
© 2000 Oxford University Press
Original Papers |
Architectural and physiological heterogeneity within the synflorescence of the pseudoviviparous grass Poa alpina var. vivipara L.
1 Department of Biological Sciences, University of Durham, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
2 NERC Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Bangor Research Station, Orton Building, Deiniol Road, Bangor, Gwynedd LL57 2UP, UK
Received 17 December 1999; Accepted 9 June 2000
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Many biotypes of the northern-hemisphere Arctic-Alpine grass Poa alpina L. reproduce asexually via prolification of the spikelet axis to produce dehiscing shoots. Although capable of photosynthesis, the sourcesink characteristics of these synflorescence systems are unknown, including the degree to which plantlets from different regions of the synflorescence are capable of providing for their own carbon requirements, or contributing to other sinks. Photosynthetic rates within the paracladial zone, as determined by infrared gas analysis (IRGA), exceeded respiratory rates by 34-fold. 14CO2 tracer studies determined that the paracladial zone was not only as efficient at fixing carbon as the youngest fully expanded leaf (per unit dry weight), but that both organs exported carbon mainly basipetally (cf. extensive acropetal export from this leaf in seminiferous grasses). Distal plantlets of the paracladial zone fixed approximately 20% more 14CO2 than did proximal plantlets. This was by virtue of their greater dry weight. At dehiscence, distal plantlets were more likely to become established, and possessed relative growth rates more than 10 times those of proximal plantlets. Paracladial heterogeneity was also apparent as an increased proportion of aborted spikelets on proximal paracladia. The possible causes of this heterogeneity are discussed.
Key words: Photosynthesis, carbon, partitioning, sourcesink relationships, inflorescence, heterogeneity.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Pseudoviviparous grasses have the ability to reproduce asexually by means of vegetative plantlets. After dehiscing from the parent plant, plantlets root and establish quickly in short growth seasons (Lee and Harmer, 1980
The spikelets of many grasses are capable of fixing carbon, and are of considerable importance to the development of caryopses (Porter et al., 1950
; Thorne, 1966
). Indeed, in the case of Poa annua L., it was determined that 2025% of 14CO2 incorporated into the caryopses at 14 d after inflorescence exertion was initially fixed within the inflorescence (Ong and Marshall, 1975
). Ong et al. stated that the inflorescence of P. annua, and that of Lolium perenne L., was the most active assimilatory organ of the reproductive tiller (Ong et al., 1978
), with all parts of the inflorescence (except caryopses) fixing 14CO2; 4050% of which was accounted for by the lemmas and paleas. Nomenclature of grasses follows Hubbard (Hubbard, 1984
).
It was previously determined that pseudoviviparous plantlets of Festuca vivipara (L.) Sm. do photosynthesize (Lee and Harmer, 1980
). However, the extent to which pseudoviviparous plantlets are self-sufficient in terms of carbon supply remains poorly understood.
The concept of carbon fixation by plantlets poses further questions: (a) is assimilation by plantlets the sole source of carbon for plantlet development after their exertion from the surrounding leaf sheath? (b) are rates of carbon fixation in plantlet leaves equivalent to those of homologous parent plant leaf-blades and (c) does export of carbon occur from the paracladial zone (i.e. the region of repeated inflorescence modules, or paracladia, comprising the reproductive synflorescence; Vegetti and Anton, 1995
)
Any investigation of the physiological relationships between organs such as paracladia must first determine their spatial and temporal relationships. For example, in three varieties of rice (Oryza sativa) the pattern of development within the paracladial zone was hierarchical, with distal paracladia being further developed than proximal paracladiathere being a gradient in physiological time along the rachis (Mohapatra and Sahu, 1991
; Mohapatra et al., 1993
). This was also observed in grasses in general (Arber, 1934
). In addition, the architecture of the paracladial zone in rice differed spatially, with larger numbers of spikelets being produced by proximal paracladia (and caryopses from these being quite poor [sic]). An initial aim of the present study was, therefore, to describe the reproductive architecture in order to provide a physical context in which to consider the physiology of this structure.
| Materials and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Plant growth
The biotype of Poa alpina, cultivation and inflorescence-induction methods used were identical to those detailed recently (Pierce et al., 2000
Structure of the synflorescence
Morphological maps were made of the paracladial zone of six replicate synflorescences, the presence and relative position of plantlets and aborted spikelets being noted. The synflorescence of the main axis from separate plants, 20 d after exertion of the distal florescence from the sheath of the youngest leaf on the axis, was used.
Gas exchange within the paracladial zone
Gas exchange within the paracladial zone was determined by infrared gas analysis (IRGA) using an ADC LCA 4 and a reconfigured conifer-type leaf cuvette (PLC 3; ADC Bioscientific, Pindar Road, Hoddesdon, Herts., UK). The entire paracladial zone was enclosed within the cuvette, with no culm tissue included. Light was provided using 250 W metal-halide lamps (model HGI/NDL; FGL Lighting Ltd., Pinewood Studios, Bucks., UK), and plant tissue temperature measured using an independent thermistor, placed in direct contact with plant tissue. Instantaneous net photosynthetic rate was measured at a photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) of 500 µmol m-2 s-1 incident at the plant tissue surface, and at a temperature of 20 °C. Air flow within the cuvette was maintained at a constant rate of 300 ml min-1. Respiratory rates were measured by enclosing the cuvette in aluminium foil to exclude light, at 19 °C. Leaf area within the paracladial zone was determined by analysis (Delta-Tscan; Delta-T Devices Ltd., Burwell, Cambridge, UK) of leaf images created using a flatbed scanner (ScanJet 4c; Hewlett-Packard Ltd., Bracknell, Berks, UK).
Measurements were made from a population of plants at various stages of development up to 21 d after exertion, but not before 7 d, as proximal paracladia had not yet emerged at this time.
C-14 pulse-labelling experiments
Pulse labelling of tissue was conducted using the protocol of Farrar (Farrar, 1993a
), in which various organs (detailed below) were supplied with 14CO2. The source of activity was Na214CO3 (Amersham Life Sciences Ltd., Little Chalfont, Bucks., UK), with an activity per feed of 10 µCi
370 kBq.
A pulse-feed of 20 min duration was applied to the chosen plant part using either the PLC 3 IRGA cuvette, or a smaller hand-built cuvette (S Gunn and JF Farrar, unpublished results), at 20 °C and a PPFD of 700 µmol m-2 s-1. The pulse feed was followed by a 2 h chase period at 20 °C and a PPFD of 700 µmol m-2 s-1. Four unfed control plants directly neighbouring the pulse-fed plants were used to monitor possible refixation of respiratory 14CO2.
Following the chase period, pulse-fed plants were dissected into their component organs (depending on the particular experiment) and each component dried to constant weight in a forced-air oven at 70 °C. Dried tissue samples were later oxidized (OX400 Biological Sample oxidizer; Lab. Impex Systems, Wimborne, Dorset, UK). The 14CO2 evolved was trapped in OxosolTM C14scintillant (National Diagnostics, Hessle, Hull) and radioactivity counted (liquid scintillation counter; WinSpectral 1414; EG and G Wallac Ltd., Milton Keynes, UK). A blank containing scintillant was used to remove the background activity from all data. The following experiments were conducted:
lpar;1lpar; Feeding of 14CO2 to first leaf or entire paracladial zone of parent plant
The first leaf (the distal leaf on the peduncle, including the blade, sheath and sheathed internode) of plants at 20 d from paracladial exertion, and also the entire paracladial zone of a further group of plants, were pulse-fed using the PLC 3 cuvette.
lpar;2lpar; Feeding of 14CO2, following physical manipulation of the paracladial zone
Also at 20 d from exertion, the distal half (by spikelet number) of the paracladial zone of six replicate plants was removed with a razor blade under water, discarded, and the cut rachis of the parent plant sealed with silicon grease, leaving only the proximal half of the paracladial zone attached to the parent plant. In a further six replicates the paracladia from the proximal two rachis nodes (i.e. proximal half by spikelet number) were removed, discarded, and stumps on the parent rachis sealed. Six control plants were left intact. Treated plants were left for 24 h before pulse-feeding of the first leaf using the PLC 3 cuvette.
lpar;3lpar; Feeding of 14CO2 to the culm of the parent plant
A portion of the distal internode of the culm was pulse-fed at 20 d from paracladial exertion. Manipulation treatments identical to those detailed in Experiment 2 were also imposed on the paracladial zones of a second group of plants at 7 d after paracladial exertion (i.e. when proximal paracladia had emerged and were available for manipulation), with either the distal or proximal half removed. Control plants were left intact. Eight replicate plants of each treatment were harvested destructively at 7 d from exertion, and at two subsequent harvests, each 7 d apart. Relative growth rate (RGR) of attached plantlets was then determined (using the equation of Hunt, 1990
).
Establishment of plantlets, post-dehiscence from the parent plant
Plantlets were removed from 20 plants at the time of cessation of culm elongation growth (i.e. when plantlets first readily dehisced; Pierce et al., 2000
). From each plant a plantlet from the distal end of the paracladial zone, and a single plantlet from the proximal end were removed; providing 20 plantlets from each position. Ten plantlets from each position were placed immediately in labelled sealed envelopes and dried in an oven at 60 °C for 24 h, and dry weights taken. The remaining 10 plantlets from each position were sown (pedicel down) in seed trays containing washed silver sand, and covered with a sheet of glass to prevent excessive water loss. Trays were placed in an alpine greenhouse (maximum temperature 21.9±0.9 °C, minimum 8.8±0.4 °C averaged over the course of the experiment, with natural illumination of approximately 16 h daily duration) and watered on alternate days with distilled water. After 30 d the number of plantlets surviving was recorded, material was dried and dry weights obtained.
Root growth in dehisced plants
Six distal and six proximal plantlets were divided between three Petri dishes. Petri dishes each contained 10 layers of Whatman No. 1 filter paper (8.5 cm diameter), moistened with distilled water on which plantlets were placed each with their basal end in contact with the filter paper (modified from Harmer and Lee, 1978
). Petri dishes were placed in a growth room at 15 °C with a PPFD of 450 µmol m-2 s-1 for 20 d with further distilled water added on alternate days using a wash bottle. On the emergence of roots, the oldest root was marked with a spot of red indelible marker ink. Every third or fourth day the number of roots was counted and the length of the oldest root measured.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Architecture of the paracladial zone of P. alpina
The main axis was hapaxanthic (terminating with the reproductive structures), and paracladia were ultimately monotelic (terminating in a spikelet), i.e. it was a closed system (Cámara-Hernández and Rua, 1991
|
The proportion of the total number of spikelets borne on each node decreased acropetally along the rachis, with 48.6±1.2% of spikelets being borne on the proximal two rachis nodes (Fig. 2b
0.001). An equivalent relationship was seen between internode number and the length of the internode, with internodes becoming shorter with distance acropetally along the rachis (Fig. 2c
0.001).
|
A number of spikelets were aborted (i.e. did not possess florets or plantlets). Such spikelets were represented by either a pair of green glumes (identical in external appearance to a young spikelet in which florets were not yet visible), a pair of withered brown glumes or by a withered mass. The proximal node possessed the greatest proportion of aborted spikelets (Fig. 2d
Carbon fixation
Net photosynthetic rate of the paracladial zone was three to four times that of the respiratory rate (P
0.001; Fig. 3
), with the difference between these rates increasing over time (P=0.018).
|
During the 14C pulse-feeding experiment 1, unlabelled control plants had a 14C content of 0.02±0.005 Bq mg-1 DW, with unfed regions of pulse-fed plants exhibiting 14C contents two orders of magnitude higher (4.8±0.8 Bq mg-1 DW with the first leaf pulse-fed, or 5.9±0.9 Bq mg-1 DW with the panicle pulse-fed, i.e. reassimilation of respiratory derived 14CO2 was minimal and values in unfed parts of pulse-fed plants represent export from pulse-fed regions). Of the 14C fixed by the first leaf on the main axis, 83% was retained in the leaf after a 2 h chase period (Fig. 4a
0.05; Table 1a
|
|
The absolute 14C content of plants pulse-fed via the paracladial zone (4.4±0.6 kBq per plant) was approximately four times that of plants fed via either the first leaf (1.2±0.1 kBq per plant) or the culm (Fig. 4c
Development and establishment of plantlets post-dehiscence
In the treatment with intact parent plants, plantlets from the distal region of the paracladial zone attained a higher dry weight than did plantlets from the proximal region (Fig. 5a
, b
; Table 2a
). Plantlets from both distal and proximal regions exhibited decreasing RGRs with increasing time from exertion (Fig. 5c
; P
0.05).
|
|
In treatments where proximal plantlets were excised from the parent plant paracladial zone, the remaining distal plantlets showed no difference to their counterparts, on intact plants, with respect to final dry weight attained or RGR of distal plantlets (Fig. 5a
Adventitious roots arose extra-vaginally through the leaf-sheaths at the base of plantlets. The number of roots produced by distal plantlets was not significantly different from the number produced by proximal plantlets (Fig. 6a
). However, the length of the oldest root produced by distal plantlets was arithmetically, and at three time points significantly, greater than that of proximal plantlets (P
0.05; Fig. 6b
; see also Table 2b
). The final dry weight of these plantlets was 5.3±0.4 mg (distal) and 3.1±0.5 mg (proximal); significantly different as determined by Student's t-test (P
0.001). The relative growth rate of distal plantlets (0.042±0.004 g g-1 d-1) on establishment in sand culture was over 10 times that of proximal plantlets (0.004±0.002 g g-1 d-1, P
0.001). In addition, proximal plantlets expressed a mortality rate of 30% over this 30 d period, whereas all the distal plantlets survived.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gas exchange data disclose that the respiratory requirements of the paracladial zone could be met by photosynthesis within the paracladial zone itself. As pseudoviviparous plantlets do not accumulate storage compounds (Lee and Harmer, 1980
Although the paracladial zone in general exhibits efficient photosynthesis, this may be consolidated mainly in the leaves of plantlets, which possess the high surface area/volume characteristics of parent leaves and are ideal for efficient gas exchange. Other organs, such as the rachis, may well be chlorenchymatous, but possess morphological characteristics suited to their mechanical role, rather than for optimizing gas exchange. For example, photosynthesis does occur in the culm, but with an efficiency approximately a fifth of parent leaf or general paracladial photosynthesis (Fig. 4d
), perhaps subsidizing, but not necessarily fulfilling this organ's requirements for carbon.
Photosynthetic activity per se of plantlets from all regions of the paracladial zone was equal at 20 d (Table 1a
). However, in absolute terms more carbon was fixed by plantlets in the distal half by virtue of the higher dry weights of these plantlets. At this point in time, distal plantlets had been exposed to an environment suitable for gas exchange and light capture for a longer period, and were conceivably at a more advanced developmental stage than proximal plantlets, the paracladial zone exhibiting the gradient in physiological time along the axis observed previously (Mohapatra et al., 1993
).
However, this cannot explain why attached proximal plantlets only achieved comparable RGRs to distal plantlets if distal plantlets were removed from the system (and not vice versa), RGRs of proximal plantlets remaining low throughout development in intact synflorescences (Fig. 5c
). Manipulation and 14C feeding experiments show that limited allocation of carbon from parental sources had a similar tendency to increase to both distal and proximal paracladial regions when the reciprocal region was removed (Table 1b
). Thus competition for parental carbon is unlikely to explain the observed RGR response (conceivably organs other than plantlet leaves form paracladial sinks dedicated to parental sources, perhaps accounting for the small amounts of acropetal transport in the system). Equally, heterogeneity is unlikely to result from competition for nutrient resources, as P. alpina grown at different nutrient regimes retains paracladial heterogeneity, which thus appears to be inherent to the system (Pierce, 1998
). Such heterogeneity, also in terms of the frequency of the observed spikelet abortion, may result from a hierarchy of phytohormonal dominance in the synflorescence systems of other grass species (Patel and Mohapatra, 1992
).
The heterogeneity observed is somewhat analogous to fruit production in many seminiferous plants that initiate more fruits than can be supported by the available resources. A proportion of these fruits grow in a typical fashion, with the remainder being relatively undeveloped. Underdeveloped fruits are viewed as a reserve which may rapidly resume development should either more resources become available or the more highly developed fruits dehisce (Lee, 1980
). Should distal plantlets of Poa alpina be lost due to dehiscence, proximal plantlets may then attain an equivalent dry weight (Fig. 5a
, b
) and will presumably become as effective as propagules. Thus the organization of the synflorescence system results in a proportion of plantlets which are vigorous and well able to establish (i.e. distal plantlets), with the remainder held in reserve for rapid growth, rather than all of the plantlets being water-stressed to a relatively high degree (plantlets in all pseudoviviparous species tested experience water stress if they remain attached to the parent plant; Lee and Harmer, 1980
) and less likely to establish and compete effectively.
The architectural study of the paracladial zone revealed that the length of rachis internodes was proportional to the number of spikelets borne on each rachis node, with 49% of plantlets being borne on the proximal two nodes. This arrangement in seminiferous grasses (from which pseudovivipary is the derived condition) would allow for effective spacing of the denser proximal paracladia, possibly facilitating air movement for pollination. The selective advantage of possessing a larger proportion of spikelets on proximal paracladia which requires spacing remains unclear. One possible advantage may be a lower centre of gravity, which would effectively reduce the bending moment acting on the culm and aid the mechanical support of the paracladial zone whilst maximizing caryopsis production. Another possibility is that spikelets are more evenly distanced from parental sources, acting to equalize flux between the source and numerous sinks and therefore resource allocation between caryopses (Cook and Evans, 1983
; Farrar, 1993b
). Retained by pseudoviviparous biotypes, this architecture is likely to be beneficial for other reasons, the spacing of proximal paracladia ensuring less shading between plantlets and thus maximizing photosynthesis. However, the relationship between space and shading is dynamic as plantlets are indeterminate, with further leaves being produced (Pierce, 1998
).
Regarding the whole plant, the majority of 14C exported from the first leaf after 2 h was exported basipetally, indicating that the paracladial zone was not in itself as important a source of carbon for parental sinks as parental sources were. In seminiferous Poa annua the first leaf mainly allocated 14C acropetally to the developing caryopses, with only older leaves supplying roots and developing tillers (Ong and Marshall, 1975
). Therefore the data indicate that photosynthesis in the paracladial zone results in a whole-plant sourcesink hierarchy in which the leaves on the main axis provide photoassimilate primarily for roots and developing tillers, rather than for propagules.
The small proportion of 14C exported from labelled organs in the present study was no doubt the result of the short chase period employed, although this was intended to provide a clearer picture of carbon fixation patterns, and also respiratory loss and refixation of 14C was minimised (Atkinson and Farrar, 1983
; Farrar, 1993a
). A more detailed study could precisely determine the location of sink tissues within the synflorescence and give a more extensive account of the sourcesink hierarchy of the whole plant.
In conclusion, the paracladial zone of a pseudoviviparous biotype of Poa alpina was a source of 14C that was as efficient as the youngest leaf on the axis, capable not only of providing for its own carbon requirements but also of exporting photoassimilate. In addition, carbon allocation from the youngest leaf on the main axis was mainly basipetal; a source of carbon for parental sinks not usually available to seminiferous grasses. Heterogeneity was observed within the paracladial zone, with distal plantlets possessing higher relative growth rates and hence higher dry weights, resulting, at dehiscence, in more rapid root growth and a higher likelihood of establishment and survival than proximal plantlets. Further heterogeneity was noted with regard to paracladial architecture and to the degree of spikelet abortion, which was greater in the proximal region.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank Professor John Farrar for hosting and advising upon- and Gareth Glyn Williams for technical support throughout- the 14C experiments. Professor Howard Griffiths is thanked for comments on an early draft the manuscript. SP was supported by a University of Durham PhD Studentship, in collaboration with the NERC Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Bangor Reseach Unit.
| Notes |
|---|
3 To whom correspondence should be addressed. Fax: +44 191 374 2417. E-mail: Robert.Baxter{at}Durham.ac.uk
4 Present address: Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, PO Box 2072, Balboa, Panama City, Republic of Panama. ![]()
5 Present address: School of Agriculture and Forest Sciences, University of Wales, Bangor, Gwynedd LL57 2UW, UK. ![]()
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Arber A.1934. The Gramineae. A study of cereals, bamboo and grass. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Atkinson CJ, Farrar JF.1983. Allocation of photosynthetically-fixed carbon in Festuca ovina L. and Nardus stricta L. New Phytologist 95, 519531.
Cámara-Hernández J, Rua GH.1991. The synflorescence of Poaceae. Beiträge zur Biologie der Pflanzen 66, 297311.
Cook MG, Evans LT.1983. The roles of sink size and location in the partitioning ofassimilates in wheat ears. Australian Journal of Plant Physiology 10, 313327.
Farrar JF.1993a. Carbon partitioning. In: Hall DO, Scurlock JMO, Bolhàr-Nordenkampf HR, Leegood RC, Long SP, eds. Photosynthesis and production in a changing environment. London: Chapman and Hall, 91112.
Farrar JF.1993b. Sink strength: What is it and how do we measure it? Introduction. Plant, Cell and Environment 16, 10131046.
Harmer R, Lee JA.1978. The germination and viability of Festuca vivipara (L.) Sm. plantlets. New Phytologist 81, 745751.
Hubbard CE.1984. Grasses: A guide to their structure, identification, uses, and distribution in the British Isles. London: Penguin Books.
Hunt R.1990. Basic growth analysis. London: Unwin Hyman.
Lee JA, Harmer R.1980. Vivipary, a reproductive strategy in response to environmental stress? Oikos 35, 254265.
Lee TD.1980. Extrinsic and intrinsic factors controlling reproduction in an annual plant. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Illinois, Champaign.
Mohapatra PK, Sahu SK.1991. Heterogeneity of primary branch development and spikelet survival in rice panicle in relation to assimilates of primary branches. Journal of Experimental Botany 42, 871879.
Mohapatra PK, Patel R, Sahu SK.1993. Time of flowering affects grain quality and spikelet partitioning within the rice panicle. Australian Journal of Plant Physiology 20, 231241.
Ong CK, Corvill KE, Marshall C.1978. Assimilation of 14CO2 by the inflorescence of Poa annua L. and Lolium perenne L. Annals of Botany 42, 855862.
Ong CK, Marshall C.1975. Assimilate distribution in Poa annua. Annals of Botany 39, 413421.
Patel R, Mohapatra PK.1992. Regulation of spikelet development in rice by hormones. Journal of Experimental Botany 43, 257262.
Pierce S.1998. Resource allocation in the pseudoviviparous alpine meadow grass (Poa alpina L.). Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Durham.
Pierce S, Stirling CM, Baxter R.2000. The influence of secondary senescence processes within the culm of a pseudoviviparous grass (Poa alpina L.) on the supply of water to propagules. Journal of Experimental Botany 51, 10671075.
Porter HK, Pal N, Martin RV.1950. Physiological studies in plant nutrition. XV. Assimilation of carbon by the ear of barley and its relation to the accumulation of dry matter in the grain. Annals of Botany 14, 5568.
Thorne GN.1966. Physiological aspects of grain yield in cereals. In: Milthorpe FL, Ivins JD, eds. The growth of cereals and grasses. London: Butterworths, 88105.
Vegetti A, Anton AM.1995. Some evolution trends in the inflorescence of Poaceae. Flora 190, 255228.
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. PIERCE, C. M. STIRLING, and R. BAXTER Pseudoviviparous Reproduction of Poa alpina var. vivipara L. (Poaceae) during Long-term Exposure to Elevated Atmospheric CO2 Ann. Bot., May 1, 2003; 91(6): 613 - 622. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||






, proximal plantlets). Data represent the mean±1SE of six separate determinations. * indicates a significant difference between means (at each time point) at the P